Skip to content
Doon Forest Early Learning

Comparison

Daycare vs Nanny

The short answer

A nanny offers one-on-one care in your home with maximum flexibility, but it is usually the most expensive option and depends on one person. Licensed daycare costs far less after CWELCC, offers peers and structure, and never closes because one adult is sick. Many families choose daycare for cost and socialization, and a nanny for flexibility or multiples.

The cost math, honestly

A nanny in Ontario commonly costs twenty to twenty-five dollars an hour or more. For a fifty-hour week that is roughly a thousand dollars a week before vacation pay, holidays, and your obligations as an employer. A nanny is a job you are creating, with the paperwork that comes with it.

Licensed daycare for a child under six, after CWELCC, often costs a small fraction of that per week. For one child, daycare is usually far cheaper. The math can shift if you have two or three children at once, because a nanny's cost does not multiply by child the way daycare fees do.

Socialization and structure

Daycare gives a child a peer group, daily routines, and programming designed for their age. For many children, learning to share, wait, and play with others is a big part of the value. A nanny offers one-on-one attention but a smaller social world, unless they actively arrange playdates and outings.

For an infant, one-on-one care has real appeal. For a two or three-year-old who is ready for peers and a busy room, a centre often becomes the better developmental fit.

Reliability and illness

A nanny is one person. When they are sick, on vacation, or they quit, your care stops until you solve it. A centre stays open through staff illness because it has a team, and it follows clear policies for when a child should stay home.

Neither option removes sick days entirely. Children in any group setting catch more colds early on. But a centre does not leave you scrambling for coverage because a single caregiver is unwell.

Questions parents ask

Is a nanny more expensive than daycare?

For one child, almost always. A nanny commonly costs a thousand dollars a week or more, while post-CWELCC daycare for a child under six costs far less. The gap narrows if you have several children at once.

Is daycare or a nanny better for socialization?

Daycare, generally. A centre gives a child a peer group and daily routines built for their age. A nanny offers one-on-one attention but a smaller social world unless they arrange regular outings.

What happens when a nanny is sick?

Your care stops until you arrange backup, because a nanny is one person. A centre stays open through staff illness because it has a team.

Is a nanny better for infants?

One-on-one care has real appeal for babies, and some families choose a nanny for the first year. Many move to a centre once a child is ready for peers and a structured room.

Do I become an employer if I hire a nanny?

Generally yes. A nanny is usually your employee, which brings payroll, vacation pay, and other obligations. That is part of the true cost to weigh against daycare.

Have a question we did not answer?

We would rather you ask than guess. Send us a note or book a tour and walk through during a regular day.